BEST MAGIC THE GATHERING MTG BOOSTER BOX TO BUY FOR 2023

Tired of the same old draws? Your quest for the perfect Magic: the Gathering MTG booster box ends here. Immerse yourself in a selection of cards designed to supercharge your collection, decks, and fun, and lead you to victory.

For 2023 there are 3 distinct possibilities to answer the question “What is the best Magic: the Gathering booster box?

  1. If money were no object, what’s the best MTG booster box for a collector?
  2. What’s the best new Magic: the Gathering booster box for 2023?
  3. What’s the best booster box of Magic under $300 to hold a booster draft?

The main reasons for buying a booster box of Magic the Gathering cards are to build a collection of cards, to use them in constructed decks, or to use them for a booster draft tournament. With that in mind, we’ll examine the above three questions and provide the best possible answer for each to explain, what are the best booster boxes.

If money were no object, what’s the best MTG booster box for a collector?

Clearly, the answer to this question would be a box of Alpha with the chance to pull a couple of Alpha Power 9 cards. However, with the limited printing and age, a sealed box of Alpha booster packs is an extremely rare find and could go for upwards of $50,000. 

MTG Power 9 cards

**Disclaimer – As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. monocolormagic.com is a participant in the GoAffPro Affiliate Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to the partner site. Through other affiliate relationships, any links that direct you somewhere else to make a purchase may result in this website making a small commission.**

With Magic being the biggest collectible card game, with a storied history of different sets, you can find several others that would be an excellent choice. Legends would be a great option to go pull a first legendary creature card like the Elder Dragons.

MTG Elder Dragon Legend cards

Or Arabian Nights would be a perfect set, if you could find those boxes. Single packs run thousands of dollars. 

The absolutely legendary cards that can be found in those sets may prove them the best boosters if you have 30 grand laying around and can find the right box.

If you’re looking for the best answer to this question, it must be a sealed booster box of the Revised MTG set from 1994. Revised boosters are still easily found on eBay and other marketplaces. Revised may not pack the Power 9 punch, but it does offer the first printing of several cards that are still highly playable. 

In a booster box of Revised look for Lightning Bolts, Swords to Plowshares, and Counterspells as first-run prints.

Not to mention the final printing of the original Dual Lands.

MTG Revised set dual lands

I opened 3 boxes of revised between 1994 and 1995. I had all but one of the dual lands and at least one of every major rare. There are definitely days I beat myself up over all of the trading and buying and selling that happened with those cards. I still have a few of the dual lands, but I was trading them then as $15 cards. Today they can go for $200 to $800 pretty regularly. You can check out the current prices on TCGPlayer here:

The outstanding mix of age, rarity, ability to get the first printing of staple cards, and the last printing of the original Dual Lands makes landing a booster box of Revised a collector’s dream. This box can be yours for the low low price of about $12,000 – $20,000 based on today’s eBay listings.

What’s the best new Magic: the Gathering booster box for 2023?

There’s not much question about this one. The best set, and thus best booster box to release in 2023 is going to be The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth. This is one of the most anticipated sets in years due to the crossover with J.R.R. Tolkien’s classic masterpiece series The Lord of the Rings.

MTG Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Universes Beyond banner

Magic has had some interesting, even great crossovers throughout the last several years with Dungeons and Dragons, Kaiju, Transformers, The Walking Dead, and other external universe characters making appearances, but this Lord of the Rings set has to be, by far, the most sought after, talked about, and sky-high expectations for release that Wizards of the Coast has seen in a long time.

To explain which booster box from the MTG The Lord of the Rings set might meet your needs and expectations, we’ll give a brief rundown of the different types of booster boxes offered. Yes, if you’re new or returning to the game after some time away, there are 3 different Magic: the Gathering booster boxes now with unique qualities tailored to collectors, players, and booster draft tournaments. All of these boosters will include uncommon cards and common cards that will be playable in the standard or modern format among others.

Set Boosters are designed for players who want to open packs for fun, boost their decks, or build their collections. Set booster packs contain a guaranteed rare card or mythic rare card, a guaranteed traditional foil card, and a variety of other cards, including basic lands, tokens, and art cards.

Set boosters also have a chance to contain a card from The List, which is a curated selection of cards from Magic’s history. Set boosters may offer the best value of the three types of booster boxes if the player doesn’t intend on drafting. With the special cards that may be included, a collector will have a better chance at pulling great cards of high value.

Draft Boosters are designed for players who want to participate in the Limited format of Magic, Booster Draft. Limited play is a format where players build decks from packs of cards that they open at the same time. Draft boosters are designed to be opened in a specific order, and they contain a variety of cards that are useful for building Limited decks. Draft boosters also contain a basic land card, a token, and a checklist card. 

Draft format may be the best way for a new Magic: the Gathering player to learn new cards as new Magic sets release, and is a great way to build up a new player’s collection. Magic: the Gathering booster draft play experience with new releases allows a player to keep up with the new mechanics that appear in the newest sets.

Every Draft pack opened will have a card of rarity “rare” or “mythic rare.” If you’re lucky with your draft deck, you may even leave your local game store after a draft with the beginning of a new deck. Or, showing up with a box of draft boosters to your play group can offer a new way to play for newer players, and a good time for all.

Collector Boosters are designed for players who want to collect cards or who want to open packs with a high chance of containing valuable cards. Collector booster boxes contain a higher number of rare cards and mythic rare cards than other types of boosters, and they also contain a variety of other premium cards, such as extended art cards, showcase cards, and foil cards.

Collector boosters are the most expensive type of booster, but they also have the highest chance of containing valuable cards. An extended art card can be highly desirable and valuable. Collector boosters can also include serialized cards which are often the most valuable cards in new sets, many times being 1 of only a few hundred made.

There is one other type of booster box worth mentioning. Jumpstart boosters, which were first released in 2020, introduced a new way to play Magic. Instead of building a deck from scratch, players combine two Jumpstart packs, each containing a semi-random, themed assortment of cards, to create a new deck ready for play.

Every Jumpstart booster includes 20 cards. All the cards in a single pack follow a theme, and most themes have multiple variations. Some jumpstart boosters even include cards from outside the main set. Jumpstart boosters may be a good option for players wanting ready-to-play decks, who aren’t interested in collecting particular cards or constructing decks for different formats.

The Lord of the Rings booster boxes are currently costing about $350 for a Collector box. About $160 for a Set booster box. And about $150 for a Draft booster box. All pre-order, with the set releasing June 23rd 2023.

All of your favorite characters from the novels can be found in this set. Gandalf, Aragorn, and the Hobbits are all there, from Frodo and Sam to Rosie Cotton. The supporting cast is there with Gimli and Legolas, Elrond and Galadriel. The villains are there featuring Sauron and Saruman. The Ents are represented, as are the Orcs. The ring plays a very important part in the set. And while left out of the movies, Tom Bombadil even makes an appearance!

MTG Tom Bombadil card

At the time of this writing the newest Magic cards sets are March of the Machine, and March of the Machine: the Aftermath. However, if you’re looking for the best MTG booster boxes of 2023’s releases, look no further than the Lord of the Rings.

I learned to draft during the Odyssey block. I have loved since those days that Magic offers so many different card games that can be played with the same cards. A trading card game that can be played constructed, or by opening packs with a random selection of cards, drafting, and throwing a deck together on the spot is brilliant. This is vastly superior to board games with a set way to play and little to no variation. You’re instead spending your money on something that can be a new experience every single time you draw it, almost no 2 games go the same, even if several of the same cards come up.

What’s the best booster box of Magic under $300 to hold a booster draft?

When choosing a booster box for booster draft, it’s important to consider the following factors:

  • Power level: You want a set with a good mix of powerful and playable cards.
  • Variety: You want a set with a variety of different card types and strategies.
  • Rarity: You want a set with a mix of good commons, uncommons, rares, and mythic rares.
  • Price: You want a set that’s affordable. 

We’ll call affordable around $300 or less for our purposes, though most recent sets can still be found under the $200 threshold for a box of boosters. And as mentioned above, if you can wait a couple of weeks you can draft with the most anticipated set of the year for about $150 per booster box.

That said, if you’re looking for the best possible booster draft experience right now, I recommend Kaladesh or Dominaria.

The Kaladesh set, with booster boxes running around that $300 mark, offers its own unique flavor and mechanics that can make drafting an exciting and strategic experience. Here are a few reasons why Kaladesh can be particularly enjoyable to draft:

  • Interesting Mechanics: Kaladesh introduced several new mechanics such as Energy, Vehicles, and Fabricate, which all require a strategic approach in draft and add layers of complexity and fun to the gameplay.
  • Balanced Colors: The set has a good color balance which means all color combinations are viable to draft. This allows for a varied and less predictable drafting experience.

  • High Power Level: Many of the cards in Kaladesh are quite powerful on their own, making it possible to draft strong individual cards as well as synergistic strategies. These include Verdurous Gearhulk and Chandra, Torch of Defiance.

Kaladesh provides a distinct and immersive drafting experience that many players have found enjoyable. If you find yourself drafting Kaladesh, here are some tips that can help you make the most of it:

  1. Understand the Mechanics: The mechanics in Kaladesh are Energy, Fabricate, and Vehicles. Understanding these mechanics is key to drafting effectively. For example, cards that generate energy are more valuable if you have cards that use energy, and creatures with low power but high toughness can be useful for crewing Vehicles.
  2. Balance Synergy and Power: Kaladesh is a set that rewards synergies, but don’t ignore the raw power of a card. While an energy-based strategy can be strong, there will also be situations where a powerful standalone card like Verdurous Gearhulk is simply the best pick.
  3. Value Removal Highly: Efficient removal spells like Fatal Push are premium picks in Kaladesh. Being able to deal with an opponent’s key creatures is crucial in any format, and it’s no different in Kaladesh.
  4. Don’t Neglect Artifact Interaction: Given the high prevalence of artifacts in the set, including Vehicles, cards that can interact with artifacts—either by destroying them, controlling them, or otherwise manipulating them—are potentially more valuable.
  5. Keep Your Curve in Mind: Kaladesh offers many tempting high-cost cards, but remember to fill out your curve with lower-cost cards as well. Ensuring you can play spells consistently in the early turns is just as important as having powerful late-game threats.
  6. Watch for Color Signals: Pay attention to what colors are being passed to you. If you’re consistently seeing strong cards in a particular color late in a pack, it could be a sign that color is open and you should move into it.

Dominaria Remastered is another popular set with a lot of iconic cards. It’s also a well-designed set that’s fun to draft. The set features cards from 27 previous Magic: the Gathering sets: Alpha, Antiquities, Legends, The Dark, Fallen Empires, Ice Age, Alliances, Coldsnap, Mirage, Visions, Urza’s Saga, Urza’s Legacy, Urza’s Destiny, Prophecy, Invasion, Planeshift, Apocalypse, Odyssey, Torment, Judgement, Onslaught, Legions, Scourge, Time Spiral, Planar Chaos, Future Sight and Dominaria. There are also three cards that first appeared in Modern Horizons.

Dominaria Remastered is a fun draft limited format because it offers a wide variety of archetypes and strategies to choose from. It has an exceptional mix of power and versatility to build around. Drafting this set can be easy to find a great mana curve.

Here are some of the things that make Dominaria Remastered so fun to draft:

  • Variety of archetypes: There are many different archetypes to choose from in Dominaria Remastered, including aggro, midrange, control, and combo. This makes the format very skill-intensive, as you need to be able to adapt your strategy to your opponents’ decks.
  • Powerful creatures and spells: Spells such as Force of Will make a comeback that have long been feared by even the most experienced players. Lyra Dawnbringer and Worldgorger Dragon return providing plenty of strength for those lucky enough to open a pack containing these high-powered flyers.

  • Efficient creatures: Dominaria Remastered also features a number of efficient creatures, such as Birds of Paradise. These creatures can help you to get ahead on board, and they can put pressure on your opponents.
MTG Birds of Paradise card

  • Versatile spells: Dominaria Remastered also features a number of versatile spells such as Swords to Plowshares. These spells can be used in a variety of different situations, and they can help you to answer your opponents’ threats.
MTG Swords to Plowshares card

Overall, Dominaria Remastered is a fun and challenging draft format that offers a lot of variety. If you are looking for a rewarding draft experience, I recommend giving Dominaria Remastered a try.

Here are some tips for drafting Dominaria Remastered:

  • Pay attention to the archetypes: As mentioned above, there are many different archetypes to choose from in Dominaria Remastered. It is important to pay attention to the archetypes that are open and to draft accordingly.
  • Prioritize powerful cards: Dominaria Remastered is a powerful set, so it is important to prioritize powerful cards when drafting. The tutors in this set can be incredibly powerful in draft, as you have a good chance of getting to them, allowing you to set up your hand. Sylvan Library can also be a powerful way to set up your hand. A card like Decimate can just wreck someone’s day, and draft decks can thrive on great removal.
  • Don’t forget about the mana base: Dominaria Remastered has a strong mana base, so it is important to make sure that you have enough lands in your deck to cast your spells.

  • Be flexible: It is important to be flexible and adapt your strategy to your opponents’ decks. Remember that when you draft, every card that’s not part of your main deck is your sideboard! if you run into an opponent that gets the best of you in game 1, be sure to go through that sideboard and see if you happened to draft anything that might be better against what you saw them play that first round.

Whether you’re looking to add to your collection, jump into a booster draft, grab a couple packs and play, or pull extremely rare cards, there’s a booster box out there for you! I hope this guide helps you make the most of your booster box purchase in 2023.

What’s the best booster box you’ve ever purchased? Let us know in the comments!

Looking at a booster box or other MTG items and accessories for a gift? Check out our 2023 Christmas holiday MTG gift guide!

Like the Facebook page, and join the Mono Color Magic Facebook group to discuss all things Magic!

All cards are copyright Wizards of the Coast and many above images and symbols are trademarks of Wizards of the Coast LLC (now a subsidiary of Hasbro.)

Bryan - MCM
Author: Bryan - MCM

Magic player since Revised in 94. Still remember opening boosters of Revised, the Dark, and Arabian Nights as a kid. Watching it be a big deal (and then let down) when Fallen Empires dropped. Then Magic got it right again and really took off. While the current state of Wizards is debatable, I still enjoy playing with friends and my kids. I don't do tournaments much these days but I've played Draft, Sealed, Standard, Extended (not a thing anymore,) Pre-Release, Grand Prix, States Qualifiers, and Teams tournaments. Though I'm not a judge, I'm the one the friends turn to when there's a rules question, and if I don't know it, I find it. Please, ask me anything, comment on posts, and share Magic with your friends and family!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *